This is the moment the war began: Tucker Carlson vs Ben ShapiroThe civil war on the right to define "America First" began during this interview 7 years ago between Ben and Tucker - The cracks were already undeniable...
Welcome to The National Discourse Don’t recognize this sender? Unsubscribe with one click Matthew Miller recently imported your email address from another platform to Substack. You'll now receive their posts via email or the Substack app. To set up your profile and discover more on Substack, click here. The schism on the right began 7 years ago in 2018 when Ben Shapiro sat down to interview Tucker Carlson about his new book “Ship of Fools” and it turned into the one of the deepest and most consequential debates about what “America First” really means and what being a conservative should mean.  Shapiro probes Tucker about certain ideas he’s written about that breach orthodox conservative economic principals, and Tucker readily admits it. Free market capitalism is a tool to reach an end, not an end in of itself, Tucker explains. Tucker elaborates that the conservative paradigm of free market/libertarian economic policy alongside neoconservative interventionism foreign policy has profoundly damaged and deprioritized the wellbeing of the regular American. He says our society is collapsing, driven by economic factors like the rapid and indiscriminate replacement of American workers with cheaper overseas labor as well as big tech innovations, criticizing two conservative economic pillars: free trade, and progress driven by the ruthless and competitive free market. Ben Shapiro grows increasingly visibly uncomfortable throughout the interview, as he realizes that Tucker is articulating a new populism right platform that is directly at odds with establishment conservatism. Shapiro then tries to discredit Tucker’s thoughts by likening it to socialist Senator Bernie Sanders’ rhetoric, which falls flat when Tucker admits there are parallels with his thinking and that of populist Democrats who’s core issues are affordability and addressing widening societal inequalities. The truth is, Trump’s MAGA platform captured blue collar Americans, the unions, and otherwise working class democrat demographics because of its tilt towards populist economics, and its parting with the CATO Institute and Heritage Foundation capitalism of the Reagan era. This schism in economics further manifests itself in foreign policy. Tucker believes whole heartedly that war is almost never in the American people’s interest unless it is a defensive war, while Shapiro acknowledges that there are ways to leverage the American military’s dominance to promote our interests around the world. The fight that we are seeing play out right now started boiling in this interview 7 years ago, and possibly earlier. It is a fight between the conservative old guard and a new populist right worldview that hopefully will not cannibalize and weaken the right, creating an opportunity for the true enemies of prosperity, the Democrats. It’s not a coincidence that the MAGA civil war erupted shortly after Charlie Kirk was killed, may he rest in peace. He was a coalition builder who successfully held the conservative movement together through Trump’s 3 campaigns, despite the cracks beginning to reveal themselves. Whichever side you are on, Tucker or Ben, intervention or non-intervention, free market or populist, we need to honor Charlie Kirk by standing together and not allowing the right to destroy itself. Rise above the noise and ask ourselves “is this productive?” We still need to have hard debates about these unignorable questions, but we need to do so in a way that doesn’t ostracize each other or attempt to silence or discredit each other, for the sake of our movement. You're currently a free subscriber to The National Discourse. For the full experience, upgrade your subscription.
|
Tuesday, March 17, 2026
This is the moment the war began: Tucker Carlson vs Ben Shapiro
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment